by Daniel X. Thomas
EP 2 430 207 B1 relates to a process for manufacturing a coated metal plate having an improved appearance.
Brief outline of the case
Opponent I attacked 1 all claims and Opponent II only attacked claims 8-11.
The oppositions were rejected and both opponents appealed.
The bord decided maintenance according to AR1 filed in appeal.
by Daniel X. Thomas
Brief outline of the case
The OD revoked the patent and the proprietor appealed.
The OD found that the opposition was admissible and that the claimed subject-matter did not involve an inventive step.
The board held the opposition admissible and confirmed the revocation.
The board refused a request for enlargement by at least one additional legally qualified member.
by Daniel X. Thomas
EP 2 443 126 B1 relates to a molecule, simalikalactone E (SkE), and its use as medicament.
Brief outline of the case
The opposition was rejected and the opponents appealed.
The board confirmed the revocation.
Background of the patent
It was acknowledged in the patent that the Quassia amara plant had been used in traditional medicine against fevers and malaria throughout the north-western Amazon and as far afield as Central America.
by Daniel X. Thomas
EP 3 338 077 A1=WO 2017/029344 A1 relates to a system and method for laser based internal analysis of gases in a human body.
Brief outline of the case
The ED refused the application by not admitting some requests, considered one comprising added-matter and the last one lacking (AR3a) clarity.
The applicant appealed.
by Daniel X. Thomas
EP 2 055 483 B1 relates to a display device for machines for processing printing substrates.
Brief outline of the procedure
The patent was maintained in amended form by the OD.
Following an appeal of opponent 3, the patent was revoked by decision T 1786/16.