In 2024, the Examination Board will be more strict on the rules for conduct. So, all candidates need to read the requirements and COMPLY with them.
Updates on EPC, PCT, EPO case law and the e-EQE
Calendars for EQE 2024
Up-to-date exam calendars can be downloaded with the link. Please pass on quickly to any EQE candidates – – the D exam will be held on 5 Mar 2024 and the PE on 15 Mar 2024. With a summary about the 10-d rule changes which are likely to be tested.
T 2020/20 – Signature of a decision by a member not having participated in the OP before the first instance division = Substantial Procedural Violation
by Daniel X. Thomas
The application relates to lubricating oil compositions, especially for heavy duty diesel engines.
Brief outline of the case
Following a second communication according to R 71(3), a second set of third party observations was filed.
The admissibility of the third-party observations, the MR, AR 1 and 2 were discussed during an OP.
T 614/21 - A party prevailing in opposition proceedings is not relieved from its duty to timely prepare its case for the event of subsequent appeal proceedings
by Daniel X. Thomas
The patent relates to a communication system for providing data communication to a vehicle, for example a train.
Brief outline of the case
The opposition was rejected and the opponent appealed.
Contrary to the OD, the board found claim 1 as granted as lacking N over D5=US 2011/0296006.
AR1-7 filed when entering appeal were not admitted under Art 12(4) RPBA.
T 3241/19 – A word of warning to applicants appealing a decision of refusal
by Daniel X. Thomas
The patent relates to an arrangement for subsea cooling of power electronic cells.
Brief outline of the case
At the end of the OP before the ED, the latter decided that a patent could be granted on the basis of AR2. The ED issued a corresponding communication under R 71(3) in which it was explained why the higher ranking requests were not allowable.